Low-Fat Mayonnaise Alternatives – Smart Swaps That Still Taste Great

The best low-fat mayonnaise alternatives are Greek yogurt, avocado, and hummus, offering rich texture and flavor with fewer calories and healthier fats. These smart swaps let you enjoy creamy dressings and sandwiches without compromising on nutrition or taste.

Whether you’re cutting calories, avoiding processed ingredients, or just looking for healthier options, you don’t have to give up creamy condiments. Many plant-based and whole food options work beautifully as mayo substitutes in both salad dressings and spreads.

Why Replace Mayonnaise?

Traditional mayonnaise is rich in fats, especially from oils and eggs. While fine in moderation, it’s high in calories and not always aligned with low-fat or plant-based diets.

Health and Lifestyle Benefits of Replacing Mayo

Here are a few key reasons to explore healthier substitutes:

• Lower in saturated fat and calories
• Dairy-free and vegan options available
• Adds fiber, vitamins, or probiotics depending on the substitute

Top Low-Fat Mayonnaise Alternatives

These versatile ingredients mimic mayo’s creamy consistency while delivering better nutrition.

Greek Yogurt

Greek yogurt is a protein-rich, tangy substitute that works great in dressings and dips.

• Nutrient benefits: High protein, calcium, and probiotics
• Best use: Salad dressings, potato salad, creamy sandwich spreads

Tip: Use plain, unsweetened Greek yogurt for best results.

Avocado

Mashed avocado offers a rich, buttery mouthfeel and healthy fats.

• Nutrient benefits: Packed with fiber, potassium, and heart-healthy fats
• Best use: Sandwich spreads, wraps, and pasta salads

Tip: Blend with lemon juice or lime to keep the color fresh and enhance flavor.

Hummus

Hummus delivers creaminess with a savory, garlicky profile.

• Nutrient benefits: Chickpea-based, full of plant protein and fiber
• Best use: Wraps, grain bowls, and veggie dips

Tip: Choose low-oil hummus or make your own to control fat content.

Cottage Cheese

Blended cottage cheese is a high-protein, low-fat alternative with a mild flavor.

• Nutrient benefits: High in casein protein and low in fat
• Best use: Salad dressings, dips, and sandwich spreads

Tip: Blend until smooth and mix with herbs or lemon for better flavor.

Mustard-Based Blends

Combining mustard with yogurt or olive oil creates a tangy, low-fat dressing base.

• Nutrient benefits: Virtually fat-free; helps emulsify sauces naturally
• Best use: Vinaigrettes, sandwich spreads, egg salad alternatives

Tip: Add a dash of honey for balance if using strong Dijon mustard.

Store-Bought Low-Fat and Vegan Mayo Options

For convenience, there are several store-bought options that skip the excess fat without sacrificing taste.

Recommended Brands

These brands focus on clean ingredients and improved macros:

• Sir Kensington’s Avocado Oil Mayo (Vegan version): Low-fat and egg-free
• Hellmann’s Low-Fat or Light Mayo: Familiar taste with 60% less fat
• Chosen Foods Vegan Mayo: Made with aquafaba, lower in fat than classic mayo

Check labels to avoid high sugar or fillers, even in light products.

Best Uses for Low-Fat Mayo Alternatives

These alternatives work in most recipes where traditional mayonnaise is used.

Where to Use These Substitutes

From dips to dressings, here’s how to use them effectively:

• Creamy dressings: Blend yogurt, hummus, or avocado with lemon juice and herbs
• Sandwich spreads: Use hummus, avocado, or mustard blends instead of mayo
• Salads: Try Greek yogurt or blended cottage cheese in tuna, egg, or potato salads

Tip: Adjust seasoning when substituting, as some alternatives like Greek yogurt are tangier than mayo.

Transitioning to Healthier Options

Switching from regular mayo doesn’t have to be abrupt. Start small and gradually adjust recipes.

Tips for a Smooth Switch

Follow these steps to adapt your taste buds:

• Start with a half-and-half mix: Combine mayo and a substitute like Greek yogurt
• Season boldly: Use lemon juice, herbs, garlic, or spices to elevate flavor
• Experiment with textures: Blend if needed for a smooth finish

Over time, you’ll naturally crave the fresher, lighter taste of these swaps.

FAQs About Low-Fat Mayonnaise Alternatives

Here are some questions and answers about low-fat mayonnaise alternatives to help you make informed choices.

What is the healthiest alternative to mayonnaise?

Plain Greek yogurt is among the healthiest mayo substitutes—it’s low in fat and calories, high in protein, and adds a creamy texture perfect for dressings and dips.

Can avocado replace mayo in sandwiches?

Yes. Mashed avocado provides a rich, satisfying texture and heart-healthy fats, making it a perfect mayo replacement for toast, wraps, or sandwiches.

Is hummus a good substitute for mayonnaise?

Hummus is an excellent substitute—it’s lower in fat (especially if oil-free), high in plant protein, and works well as a spread or dressing base.

How can I make my own low-fat mayonnaise?

Combine plain Greek yogurt with lemon juice, mustard, garlic, and a bit of olive oil to mimic the taste and consistency of mayo with fewer calories.

Do store-bought light mayonnaises still contain fat?

Yes, but typically 50–60% less than regular mayo. Always read the label to ensure the fat reduction is not offset by added sugars or fillers.

Back to Mustard & Mayonnaise